OKSANA HOMYaKOVA

Saved 1/28/19 5:24 AM to Russia and USSR

Кepчeнcкий Инцидeнт. Детализация позиции.  See details »

 
Video subtitles:
  • 00:00:00: Hello dear subscribers I decided to make a video of my own Pushchino turns video on Kerch intsindent and I remember already gave comments on this topic hot footsteps as they say and positions since I basically have not changed a rather detail and this time by two months to two months since the events at live here so time flies quickly I think you can already
  • 00:00:32: speak in more detail the position and to evaluate those events in terms of international treaties of international rights in part of the maritime convention right and proper legislation Russian Federation for which, too, and At times, there are questions movie I I remember writing down just in parallel so as deputies of the Supreme Council voted but let's say hybrid
  • 00:01:02: version of the semi military semi position on semi ukraine and private floor wichita here arises from the fact that the president Poroshenko initially signed a decree on imposition of martial law for 60 days all over Ukraine this decree is not actually here nothing unexpected according to Article 107 of the Constitution of Ukraine
  • 00:01:33: the president decides and here enter into action the decision is approximately in the title is tied the same is written decision happy national without drink this national security council and defense of Ukraine about the actual military the position that is interesting in this document, I want to draw anything attention is not always but often as we have
  • 00:02:03: know interesting interesting moments happen at the end documents are here point 3 what's in it written means this decree is gaining momentum that is, takes effect from the day it publication what does it mean it means that when President Poroshenko signed this decree and the decree was published proper start
  • 00:02:33: act then martial law version who here actually offered originally porosin songs for 60 days and it is legally military position occurred before the reaction supreme glad and proper if the supreme glad quite turned it the proposal then president poroshenko could one more decree to sign and before the next reactions of the Supreme Council and so on then
  • 00:03:03: there are no restrictions here and that's all i'm talking about talking about having a legal window when can endlessly sign decrees similar type yes corresponding reactions of the Supreme Council can be extended here as seen military the position is infinite but proper martial law for 60 days affected the beginning of the electoral
  • 00:03:34: campaigns that we are seeing now which unfolds and already in my more than 30 candidates have registered to participate in these elections but why so notable parts of the deputies Supreme Council did not agree to this version of martial law which Poroshenko originally proposed also evil tongues like dmitry gordon
  • 00:04:09: proudly how correctly than they say that presidential decision to shorten the term martial law occurred after talk his conversation with the chancellor of germany angel merkel and nato secretary general although not I know whether you can trust Gordon after him let's say so effective forecasts on other issues we all remember how dmitry gordon predicted that the world championship
  • 00:04:42: Football in Russia will not take place Nord Stream 2 will not be built well and so on but even if if Poroshenko and talked with Merkel it's not a fact that Merkel was talking to Poroshenko due to the fact that the confirmation such a conversation was never so and maybe Poroshenko could once again talk as they say with his Lexus we also should not exclude this
  • 00:05:12: well, although the park though pranker I think already would long ago published their conversation with Poroshenko if such would take place before the result was martial law on half term that is for 30 days and nina throughout Ukraine but only in certain areas and it so happened that it happened in those areas where poroshenko support is noticeably worse than in those where martial law was not introduced
  • 00:05:43: also such entertaining element of the overall picture in anyway according to my observations a little who are ordinary citizens of Ukraine felt the presence of the military position in his country well, unless there can be military and those who's there any fees got here they occasionally remembered with a kind word I assume my commander in chief this here possibly came from
  • 00:06:13: certain mode for military martial law in general, in serious declared power reasons for the introduction of military provisions do not believe either in the West no food inside the country judging by the reaction of citizens not supreme Rada though the deputies should have been I think save the face of the president at least partly because if they were completely
  • 00:06:43: would refuse to vote for the military the situation is Poroshenko with his provocation in the Kerch Strait I would have looked quite sorry for first of all before the world community but he still represents Ukraine on at least internationally so I think that the deputies at the end all done politically right with point of view of national interests
  • 00:07:13: Ukraine in general, they did so acted formally given by half accepting the president’s proposal for a military position the format itself and the presence of the military provisions caused as a result more questions to the Kiev authorities themselves because neistovali that the Crimea is not Ilovaiskaya
  • 00:07:43: tragedy is not debaltsevskoe no tragedy in the southern boiler under izvarino by the way for some reason about this rarely remember those situations in short Ukrainian army suffered heavy losses They did not deserve a state of war and Here Kerch intsindent without victims and Thank God that no victims gum rowan martial law and actually incomprehensible the formal position of Kiev which their version of the war kind of like with Russia
  • 00:08:15: for the fifth year and led martial law that's just recently a comparative total for 30 days after the end of these 30 days it is not clear what is over that is it is clear that formally ended martial law war against Russia continued in general Kiev version of the war with Russia, even here in this context not even in context simple logical analysis on the subject introduction and cancellation of martial law
  • 00:08:47: type of martial law ended before the war goes on in networks are actually all these logical inconsistencies are explained by simple logic probably Poroshenko I guess in the framework of the Kerch provocation sent their military personnel let's say so on not certain death in order to get a few victims among the Ukrainian military so get a reason for
  • 00:09:18: international scandal present Western leaders logic forced the world agenda force leaders of prominent countries of the world meet with Poroshenko thereby demonstrating Ukrainian to citizens that the west is still with us also bloody results failed provocations could temporarily upgrade Ukrainian agenda in the world about which all more and more are forgotten the farther away from 2014 also Kerch
  • 00:09:50: provocation she could allowed she could allow poroshenko to achieve the effect associations of citizens of Ukraine around his commander in front of upcoming presidential elections together so get extra the possibility of martial law these are the main goals provocations as I see them can be wrong
  • 00:10:20: estimates may be different but actually I remember everything as after 2014 after my revolution data position was quite popular which consisted in the following that the Kremlin Putin Russia made such actions who have united citizens Ukraine around the post maidan of their authorities and apparently logic logic in 2018 was
  • 00:10:51: approximately calculated on the same what will be more more serious the results of the Kerch provocation could to be victims and citizens themselves again frightened by the shock could unite around your the commander in chief is no he is around him at such a difficult time
  • 00:11:21: hard time need to team up for I want to show the demonstration how Ukrainian border guards in 2000 harassed and detained turkish poachers sank one school and you can assume that Kiev modern Kiev authorities may have counted on
  • 00:11:51: trips to a similar effect and thereby sacrificing your military for achieve their political goals on upcoming elections here is the page of alexander tori gender I links to resources that were used in this video will leave everything in video description here you can go to the page independently read here according to
  • 00:12:23: Author's Hawai that this is exclusive which appears to our attention here this view long enough article all read I will not but what is worth paying attention is an important point according to the author the ships were in exceptional marine economic zone about twenty miles from the shore Well, here we waste a little video
  • 00:12:53: away to Ukrainian military chase already drowning in my 1 schooner on this can be seen just David is trying to stop like this these schools you see here take in tow because now and now drowns just drowns
  • 00:13:23: this school then it will be now possible watch on screen like this the situation was such a practice in 2000 year for a more detailed analysis Event I think you first need restore the overall context of the the setting that was November 24 and 25
  • 00:13:55: 2018 it is just the days of the Kerch events if someone does not know I do not get tired repeat that my revolution data poverty resulting in a whole list negative effects and their derivatives both for Ukraine itself and for its the limits of what we actually observe All these long already almost 5 years in the result of the revolution is a series of rude
  • 00:14:26: violations of the Constitution of Ukraine Crimeans as we all remember the opportunity the new kremlin too helped them solve their fate in a referendum in March 2014 as a result, the Crimea became part of Russian Federation and in terms of Ukrainian-Russian relations Crimea became disputed territory from here occurs a number of consequences in particular inconsistencies in relationships related
  • 00:14:56: with the Crimea in the Sea of ​​Azov and use passages through the Kerch Strait under the newly built Crimean bridge if only because of the Crimean issues must constructively discussed at the state level between Kiev and Moscow based on the position that Crimeans demonstrated on referendum although said in March 2014 that is based on the fact that the Crimea in the composition
  • 00:15:26: Ukraine will not return but the Crimean problem is necessary permit they leave the next generation which time after time they will receive intsindent and similar to the one we observed in Black Sea near Kerch strait and the actual incidents can be worse in the future may also accompanied by human victims want to avoid this is about the general context there is also a marine context
  • 00:16:04: Kerch provocation because she is a continuation of the marine theme which opened Kiev in March 2018 through fishing boat arrest not together with his crew this is a provocation of Kiev certainly not without mirror and also disproportionate Moscow reaction because the Russian side responded arrested Ukrainian ship but formally
  • 00:16:34: there were certainly other reasons but we somehow understand that it was in fact a mirror response of Moscow to provocation Kiev disproportionate part of the reaction Moscow was that the ship heading to Ukrainian ports started inspecting will be thorough and much longer than that and the result is visible economic losses of Kiev and this is like
  • 00:17:04: This is how Moscow demonstrated disproportionate response to Kiev from the position strength Kiev from the position of the weak answer of course there was nothing because Formally, the Russian side did not rule violated while retreating from the sea side of the conflict started as i said kiev me wanted or even rather could not because the aggressive part Kiev patriotic who still
  • 00:17:35: called hawk hawks would not understand manifestation of seemingly weak collective Poroshenko therefore why Kiev went well let's say so on increasing the degree of sea conflict and decided to check the reaction Moscow on the passage of military boats of Ukraine across the Kerch Strait and the first such passage is naval Ukrainian forces carried out in September 2018
  • 00:18:06: of the year accompanied of course Russian ships that on the one hand was a confirmation that there is the possibility of the Ukrainian Navy to pass under Crimean bridge, that is, there is no there is no discrimination but they should have been follow all the rules on the other hand so understood and directive to go through the military ships under the Kerch bridge and check was to check
  • 00:18:38: Kremlin reaction was the goal to plan further provocative actions connected with the Crimea with the Crimean bridge that is, look at how it responds Moscow but also to plan further the next pass that we actually observed in November 2018 years it is necessary also not to forget about public discourse in Ukraine where also proposed to blow up the Crimean bridge
  • 00:19:10: this is at least stated the deputy Mosiychuk is but this character is not so the last in the current Verkhovna Rada of his by its influence and as I understand it such a walking spit radical parties olya lyashko it's like once this one the frame for which in the building of the Supreme Council even torsion some kind of video like
  • 00:19:41: physical evidence that MP Mosiychuk took there some bribes according to my version then already to the prosecutor lutsenko because we wanted to remove the deputy immunity with deputy moseychuk a but he managed to get away get away out of the water as they say and get away from penalties in general public discourse in public discourse are pulled out given such
  • 00:20:16: ideas how to blow up the Crimean bridge and so you can guess what for most of this policy speak as they say on the sidelines outside public space also need to understand that the Crimean bridge this is a very important strategic object on which development of the peninsula depends Crimea plus and of course it is an important image symbol that is, we remember saying spam and even here dmitriya gordon which
  • 00:20:48: I already mentioned He predicted that the Crimean bridge is not build although I could be mistaken whether said this gordon not say well it's okay in anyways public discourse we remember various experts say it is impossible to build Crimean bridge however it was built and he now also serves as a certain image symbol which of the hologram Mu-mu with the film as we know became
  • 00:21:19: reality and so from this point Of view, he is very uncomfortable with modern Kiev Moscow in general is about what worry when under the bridge pass fighting boat from that country of politics who want to blow up Crimean bridge now move on to those events which are directly related to Kerch provocation about which week warned ukrainian water
  • 00:21:49: politician named Alexander Shevchenko this is a presidential candidate from the parties dill and the party dill I will say who is not course this is a party that tight enough as I understand it is connected with Not about Petrovsky clan this Kolomoisky This filatov Gennady Korban but they there inside his chest as the quarrel about something but it's not so fundamentally easy I
  • 00:22:19: I pronounce that this party so Alexander Shevchenko on his page facebook posted post to next day after the incident here is this post who can be interested listen to what alexander says Shevchenko let's see what is written here dear friends dear Ukrainians I want to appeal to you in this difficult
  • 00:22:49: for our particular country in this difficult moment in this difficult time exactly a week ago I warned at air apparently meaning in television or radio about the fact that Poroshenko is preparing a provocation VAZ Sea for the introduction of military provisions and cancellations of presidential elections and actually this phenomenon is this phenomenon
  • 00:23:20: it is necessary to somehow explain that is possible and as peculiar to many politicians not only Ukrainian and ordinary people characteristic of the person says something gives forecasts are quickly forgotten publics are kind of like predictions and not It was but it is lucky and gets a finger in heaven and becomes the hero of the day or a few days that is more dense enters the public information this space at least increases
  • 00:23:50: rating and its recognition and for Alexander Shevchenko This is important before presidential elections here well alexander Shevchenko, he as I understand it is not a passing candidate he is far from the top 3 yes but actually if he declares himself and It is forcing himself to talk about the increasing his recognition he also raises his chances for the upcoming elections to the supreme glad I will remind they too will pass at the end
  • 00:24:23: 2019 is also possible and more realistic option that I Kolomoisky again I will explain Kolomoisky is large businessmen generally call oligarchs really as I understand it as such is he not a simple person for Ukrainian business economics policy so it is noticeable I guess greater access to information compared with ordinary citizens and he could get
  • 00:24:56: information about the one who said on his Facebook page Alexander Shevchenko and through Alexander Shevchenko reset this information in public space here but in any case in any case the outcome of the Kerch provocation military Ukrainian prosecutor's office opened a criminal case on the Kerch incident Now I will display this moment
  • 00:25:29: there is yes what is said here before in connection with the events in Kerch Strait In general, the military prosecutor's office excites criminal criminal case and since the criminal case is now reasonable will at least have a conversation with
  • 00:26:02: alexander shevchenko and find out where does he have information about preparing provocations in the Sea of ​​Azov now let's go to the map and let's follow as planned passage of military boats navy of Ukraine which there was a route and see that despite
  • 00:26:34: warning of Alexander Shevchenko Ukrainian military boats did not reach the Sea of ​​Azov and the incident itself happened in the black sea not in close proximity to the Kerch the strait in general is a way from here planned from Odessa I approximately show to so that it is visually understandable with grooves and so here the boats should were to go and actually get close to
  • 00:27:05: the Crimean peninsula get around it like that get close to Kerch Strait here to go through it and proper reach the end point namely to Berdyansk actually need to consider shipping quality of those combat boats
  • 00:27:35: who participated in the Kerch incident, these boats can withstand far from any weather conditions therefore even from this point of view, the Ukrainian the parties had certain risks therefore so if the goal was like her declared namely peacefully and moving boats from one Ukrainian port to another then faster and it was safer to do it and not it was possible to transfer boats by land
  • 00:28:07: for example tractors and without much anticipated and possible problems that is Kiev authorities should have been aware of that sending boats to such a trip reasonably expect to meet Russian sides as we already observed in September 2018 at the first passing martial to tyranny by Kerch channel and subject to all rules
  • 00:28:38: if this time it was not planned follow all the rules then actually the expected meeting could and should have been be tough what was the plan of passage a few days after the FSB incident published a checklist not capricious to master and display here is the publication of the article at 112. she was several such publications on the internet i
  • 00:29:10: kissed 112 and what we see here is this checklist Nikopol for going to sea 23 2018 23 november 2018 here's 25 here with nine am means first goal outs redeployment to Berdyansk so 2 older brother and something interesting begins
  • 00:29:40: with item 3 so what do we have to prepare for relocation of sports Odessa to the port Berdyansk through the Kerch channel exit from the port Odessa to commit through a special disposal move to commit attention covertly through covertly through outside coastal and sea observation areas Black Sea Fleet of the Russian Federation
  • 00:30:11: and the coast guard of the FSB of Russia during fulfilling the task of the main effort focus on attention hidden passes to the Kerch channel and its passage that is, it can only imagine imagine how hidden you can go through the Kerch canal when everything is there controlled by the Russian side that is, it is a clear provocation apparently conflict 4 4 so tra-ta
  • 00:30:42: start preparing the boat for attention fight and hike to fight and hike here and so Strictly follow at sea safety rules when using attention weapons of military equipment and navigational safety during fulfilling the task of the main effort focus on the hidden passes to
  • 00:31:12: Kerch channel and its passage then there is a task standing judging by this sheet go Kerch channel is hidden This is something that must also be explained . but to verify this information is logical turn your where to turn only in the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine if officially here and if really planned relocation
  • 00:31:43: fighting boats the Ukrainian side nothing to hide that actually did one of the Ukrainian editions called uk u us but on their appeal the ministry of defense Ukraine refused to classify I’ll also bring this information to there is a screen publication ukranews bring here it is means the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine
  • 00:32:17: teams scott naval forces of Ukraine so what is written here here here just in accordance with article 1.1.3 from the water statements that make up state secret approved security service of Ukraine from 12 August 2005 number 440 the requested information is one from us
  • 00:32:48: refers to information that contains state secret defense countries that's what the official says the response of the ministry of defense and proper the question arises if there was a combat order it really is sense to hide it if the combat order it was not then what to classify then
  • 00:33:18: could just use appeal of Ukrainian journalists and topics the most publish those orders are those documents that indicate peace plans of the Ukrainian side moving combat boats from Odessa to Berdyansk but information as we see was classified now go directly to
  • 00:33:54: reconstruction of events according to gpu and fsb but by the way the city is what strange cut cuts ear name of himself state body of Ukraine associated with the state political administration nkvd short for right Yes, and political prisoners condemns the sword and Ukraine 200 attention 58 articles in
  • 00:34:24: general cunning as they say spiral stories but oh well, in general there is a reconstruction reconstruction of gpu and fsb now i have them I will display here the reconstruction gpu reconstructions also have reconstruction of the FSB of Russia and it would probably not entirely correct one by one
  • 00:34:55: only go one of these reconstruction is also in the new newspaper combined version but it is unfortunately not complete, that's why i cooked its version of the combined glued from reconstruction of the Prosecutor General's Office Ukraine and actually
  • 00:35:26: FSB links to the reconstruction of omega General Prosecutor's Office of Ukraine and reconstruction FSB Federal Security Service I will leave the Russian Federation in description of this video as your own all the resources that I use so well let's go then just by the events
  • 00:35:57: here is november 23 friday group of small boats Berdyansk not a raid tug but a drunk mouth guard moved from the port of Odessa to Mariupol following in neutral waters at least you in the sheet was told about Berdyansk by the way i forgot to mention that September first transition martial boats just carried out in Mariupol November 24, Saturday 15 05 the same
  • 00:36:27: message from gpu Russian ship created qi began accompany the Ukrainian boats further at 15-17 at a height of 100 meters it also day off message and distance of 50 meters Ukrainian ship circled Russian Mi-8 helicopters in 1537 Ukrainian sailors tied to create with Suzdaltsev and message that follow on
  • 00:36:58: to the plan hit sundries noted that too should according to plan and continued escorted Ukrainian ships Means 18-35 to accompany Ukrainian ships joined the boat border FSB service with tail number 7 37 he moved parallel course well, sort of
  • 00:37:28: as given at this stage no I see no problems here Comment on the following the message we have under the hoplite it is important that it is from gpu that is from 2107 Ukrainian side FSB boat informs you about the passage rules
  • 00:37:59: Kerch Strait that is, which means Ukrainian side is aware that the rules passages of the Kerch Strait there is actually what confirm this possibility yes possibly there is but the possibility of this is not permission it is also important to clarify what it is rules such passages Kerch strait Mrs. I'll display them here.
  • 00:38:29: regulations so it should say here Russian Ministry of Transport Federation order of October 21, 2015 number 313 i.e. in November 2018 these the rules have already acted on what is this rules back to item 38 here
  • 00:39:01: interested here this item number 38 information about the vessel passes to the reception buoy vazovsky any when you pass the ship in transit from the Sea of ​​Azov or battle number one keck keck is the Kerch canal when you pass the ship from the black sea ​​captain or ship agent I submit there to the captain of the sea
  • 00:39:32: port copy to court for attention 48 hours before the passage pass again for 24 hours and finally specify 4 hours before the passage here it is also important as it is also 41 points I must say there is another possibility in case of lack of information about passed and and detention is requested essence which is guided by the actual
  • 00:40:02: the situation and the cake in the Kerch channel makes recommendations and permission to enter that is, even in this case acts authorization procedure itself I must also note that the Ukrainian the parties had similar rules at the time when Kiev controlled the Crimea, I now just and demonstrate the document site
  • 00:40:33: supreme glad some sites of law. glad . god or and link to this document me too leave in the description of the video means that this is what the ministry is order of transport of Ukraine order from 2002 number 721 we are interested in just to Here is this item of information about the approach
  • 00:41:05: the ship to the same wrestling battle during the transit of the court from Sea of ​​Azov or Oak I am number one passing ship from the black sea side that is almost one to one served by the ship’s captain or shipmaster agent 48 hours before the passage again in 24 hours and finally specified in
  • 00:41:35: 4 hours to the passage that is, these rules are these rules for the Ukrainian side is not news and actually the Ukrainian side was in the course of these programs means the following on The message is also from gpu from the general Prosecutor's offices of Ukraine 2130 Russian
  • 00:42:07: the side informs that the area is the sea before Kerch Strait is closed for passage from 10 pm November 24 until 10 pm 26 November, the reasons for closing are not explained command you gave command navy Ukraine has checked the international base data and did not find them officially established restrictions
  • 00:42:37: movement means what information we we can learn from this statement the first is that to the ukrainian side in the apple version was still brought information by the Russian side Kerch Strait closed this first the second is that since the command Air Force checked international databases
  • 00:43:10: until then respectively it is reasonable to assume that the Ukrainian seafarers actually reported closing Kerch rule in Kiev and Navy of Ukraine and checked the database in this connection in this regard is logical look and what we have is prescribed in the international treaty between Ukraine and the Russian Federation about joint
  • 00:43:43: using the Sea of ​​Azov and Kerch Strait in the treaty's us on the screen agreement between the Russian Federation Ukraine about cooperation in use of the Sea of ​​Azov and the Kerch Strait from December 24, 2003 it is important that here note that this the contract incidentally refers to that the largest cooperation agreement
  • 00:44:13: friendship and partnership between russian Federation and Ukraine from which apparently Kiev comes from from April 2019 corresponding decision and President and the Supreme Council seem to be like already voted by the way let's see how in this regard will be act new authorities which i I will remind of is taken just before the end this between
  • 00:44:44: per gallons and since this contract refers to that will see if he keep going or he too just canceled there are a few hundred leg of treaties between Ukraine and Russia no agreements just tied to a big contract and I remind you that this sharing agreement the Sea of ​​Azov and the Kerch Strait this contract of the eternal what is called because it does not registered and how to get out of it and if ukrainian side comes out of this
  • 00:45:15: the contract is probably worth reading in convention on international treaties i'm not I remember there which way the woodchuck is worth exploring what happens in such cases in the 1969 convention but I something distracted from the contract between Ukraine and Russia about joint use of the Kerch Strait and Sea of ​​Azov in important here is article 2
  • 00:45:47: that it says here that merchant ships and warships this is our military case ships as well as other state ships under the flag of the Russian Federation and Ukraine exported to non-profit purposes are used in the Azov Sea Kerch Strait of Navigation that is, the Ukrainian side agrees Of course, this agreement had the right to freedom of navigation in the Kerch Strait but actually the Russian side has closed
  • 00:46:18: Kerch Strait what was actually brought to Ukrainian T-shirts and as we saw messages ha plan and transmitted this information in Kiev, that is, did not act self on the spot ie have arisen questions have questions about freedom shipping yes that is kind of like
  • 00:46:50: Ukrainian side has the right to pass Russian side for it is not the Kerch Strait for some to this stage for your reasons so here let's read article number four what happens in such cases before the dispute between the parties related to the interpretation and application of this contract are resolved through consultation and of negotiations as well as other peaceful means the choice of the parties that is, those it must was to consult and engage
  • 00:47:24: negotiations with Moscow and instead Kiev decided to look at international the base for the presence of the closure here Kerch Strait and here we can observe that at least both the parties do not follow this agreement on this stage
  • 00:47:54: that is, on the one hand freedom shipping on the other hand according to the fourth point, Kiev should actually consult with Moscow and allow questions diplomatic methods further further we already have messages from the FSB also at 21:30 with the passage of a group of ships Ukrainian Navy State Border of the Russian Federation
  • 00:48:25: belt 302 informed them about the order crossing the state border Russian Federation and the rules of navigation on the Kerch channel which provides for the filing of an application of marine Kerch port authorities for 4824 and four hours confirmation that Ukraine’s navy ships were not made by command of the navy of Ukraine received
  • 00:48:56: the answer is that the intersection of the state borders of the Russian Federation and passage Kerch Strait ship group not planned this by versions FSB Russia what actually happened on The next day already on November 25 is aware that the Ukrainian side just crossed border of the Russian Federation
  • 00:49:27: but this version of the FSB and actually this the message is just talking about those rules 48 24 hours confirmation for four hours are exactly the rules about which I said a little earlier and demonstrated in relevant documents but what's the important point here what is the important point here in terms of Ukraine Crimea is Ukraine
  • 00:49:59: and therefore if the Ukrainian ships planned to go to the territorial waters Crimea then from their point of view here here I am simply I admit the logic of such a blow from their point they planned to enter their territorial waters which means they planned to cross the border the russian federation is just that the very moment that i was talking about misunderstanding in relations between Kiev
  • 00:50:30: and Moscow will continue here with different interpretations where there boundaries and actually all these questions It will be necessary to settle Moscow and Kiev as I said earlier but also the final message from the FSB of the Russian Federation on November 24-24 2018 at 22 23 search 302 is the ship
  • 00:51:02: brought to the ship group you naval forces of Ukraine information about the closure of the area in territorial sea of Russia is not suitable the Kerch Strait from the black seas naval group Ukraine maneuvers in exclusive economic zone of Russia at a distance of six seven seven miles from state border of Russia
  • 00:51:34: proper It should be noted that in the convention on maritime law and legislation Russian Federation provided opportunity to close and territorial of the sea, but the closing must be done advance alerts and alerts that is, to do it before, I actually searched for this alert from using Department of Defense website interface Russian Federation I do not do this
  • 00:52:04: succeeded but I found these alerts on site other methods the main thing that is this document which is now its type demonstrated here are the notices Mariners site just Department of Defense link as I have spoke on all the resources i will provide in description for this video what we are interested in here you see
  • 00:52:35: here every entry is message by navigator what happens in a particular area and for the corresponding card number such means that we are interested in us are interested in the black sea so slightly lower slightly lower here here here it is the black sea here proper
  • 00:53:05: artillery firing posts with 30 October to November 30 I remind events occurred on November 24 and November 25 as time for wings geographically district territorial sea and it's saturday but what else do you need to pay attention that in the description to the closure that it is from 5 am to 5 pm and swimming
  • 00:53:35: temporarily dangerous here in some areas there is also a second message shooting rocket and artillery with 30 October to November 30 except again sunday identical messages but for other cards from 5 am to 5 pm apparently and therefore in international databases this message was not and accordingly the Russian side can in any
  • 00:54:09: formal signs talk about what there were difficulties with shooting and therefore ban in these areas was necessary close and then this story can come up with a different main thing that ban on prohibition announcing the attraction was advance and actually necessary understand that on unless I understood
  • 00:54:41: the Russian side is an alert used on formal grounds on really really as we see because of the reconstruction of the FSB of Russia the Ukrainian side behaved suspicious and provocative with one parties judging by the reconstruction of the FSB Ukrainian ships were not going to cross the state border Russian Federation on the other hand
  • 00:55:11: that's how we read this message last for November 24 Ukrainian ship carried dangerous maneuvering directly from in direct proximity to the Kerch Strait and the application there was no reason to pass actually close Kerch Strait is how I understood this the situation is now moving
  • 00:55:43: directly to the events of November 25th and here is the first message we have from Prosecutor General's Office of Ukraine in 358 coma commander bergen went on radio service, the FSB border post Kerch and Caucasus control ports prior notice of intent cross cross 12 peace zone and
  • 00:56:14: pass the Kerch Strait I will remind that according to the FSB version earlier than 24 november Ukrainian representatives of Ukrainian ships message that cross Russian state border federations they are not going he refers to a cooperation agreement when using the Sea of ​​Azov and Kerch Strait was ready to take on board
  • 00:56:45: Russian hair minutes this interesting moment also the commander said that in plans for the passage of the Kerch Strait reported 4 hours before the very beginning passage though the version Russian side of such a warning it was not and I will remind the rule that first must be warned 48 hours later 24 hours and finally four hours maybe there is just a hidden reference to that forty first point
  • 00:57:15: when you can report your passage in 4 hours but in this case, the captain of Kerch the port when decides and actually valid permits order means I have already said that the moment is interesting here what's the version again hapon this version of gappu ukrainian side was ready to take on board
  • 00:57:45: I will now bring the Russian pilot to screen one interesting document here it is this document this is the rate and order of charging port fees in the Republic of Crimea we are interested in one point namely a charges for pilotage services just about own this paragraph 11
  • 00:58:15: for pilotage to the court in the following Kerch transit channels more cake and pilotage dues are charged later rates but these are actually rates as we see here the value of the pockets marine services it is not fundamentally important that she is not 0 I will now explain why this is important because
  • 00:58:45: that if you go through the Kerch the strait following the rules of 4824 four hours then something else that you have to pay onion lubricants and fees on the other hand, the Ukrainian side considers Crimean authorities occupying and if they pay it means thereby through recognize these actions by these authorities Actually, I remind you, I already said that in September 2018
  • 00:59:18: Ukrainian ships have already passed through Kerch Strait and it is important to note here okay these are some merchant ships under any flag here ships they represent the state of Ukraine and proper authorities consider occupying and according to the rule these authorities need pay money here and if you don't pay it means breaking the rules like this collisions in September I remember there was a scandal
  • 00:59:49: on this topic but the Ukrainian side stated that no money Russian As far as I remember, I did not pay then the question is, who paid pilotage fees as we saw pilotage fees they are not free yet what's important to pay attention here is what is the version again gpu commander Berdyansk refers to the agreement on cooperation when using
  • 01:00:20: the Sea of ​​Azov and the Kerch Strait this contract which I already demonstrated and according to the fourth clause of this contract if arise questions yes here and referring to this contract if you have questions, then you must resolve these issues diplomatically and again port and territorial not port of Kerch and territorial waters areas through native
  • 01:00:50: here were closed ie there already appeared the question is already a ban therefore in in this case to cite the contract should cues they sailors when dealing with Moscow on the topic passage of the Kerch Strait following message this time from the FSB in 535 tank Berdyansk reported on post
  • 01:01:21: technical observer about the planned the passage of the Ukrainian Navy ships tra-ta-ta in Port Berdyansk 600 Strait of Kerch Kiev time, something 7:00 Moscow time Actually but I have the main comments on I have already done this topic again. from the point of view of the Russian side ukrainian side looked
  • 01:01:55: ambiguous that is tony going they were not going to cross the border Now they say that they want to pass across the Kerch Strait after the actual Kerch the strait on the FSB version was already closed further that we have teams commander Berdyansk contacted the ship and here I will raise it right now This is according to the version according to gq 538 commander
  • 01:02:28: Berdyansk contacted coastal ship FSB guard and duplicates everything he said earlier the answer Russians took the message was accepted permission to pass was not own everything The following message we have from the psg from the Russian side, I will raise a little higher
  • 01:02:59: fsb at 5:45 commander belt 302 informed the commanders of Berdyansk as follows in order to implement rights of the russian federation as coastal state to provide maritime safety in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 12 federal for she is 155 gentle passage through Russian territorial sea
  • 01:03:32: the federation in the area is temporarily suspended about what you previously Notify advise you not to cross Russian state border federation before lifting the restrictions and implementation of mandatory regulations in masses in the seaport Kerch that is, after compliance relevant rules or obtaining permissions on the forty first point here those rules that I demonstrated
  • 01:04:02: from the ministry of transport means that here you can, let's see what written in paragraph 2 of article 12 now i'm I'll put it on the screen here is article 12 the right of peaceful passage though as previously we already judging by the sheet of the ship saw it It was not so much innocent passage and
  • 01:04:32: probably a hidden passage somehow Ukrainian military boats wanted to pass covertly across the Kerch Strait well let's read point 2 on which FSB cites for security security of the Russian Federation also for the purpose of conducting exercises with weapons of any kind federal agency defense executive federal executive body
  • 01:05:03: on security may temporarily suspend in a couple of mountainous areas territorial sea implementation of the right of peaceful passage across the territorial sea of foreign ships as well as foreign here in this case warships and other state courts such is suspended requested after advance both announcement of this in the notice navigator I just provided this document
  • 01:05:36: it was for well and the announcement is such situation but actually if ukrainian the party disagreed with that as already demonstrated according to international treaty joint using the Sea of ​​Azov and Kerch Strait in case the emergence of contradictions it is necessary to use clause 4 a use the opportunity negotiations between Kiev and Moscow
  • 01:06:08: the next reconstruction element is the same from FSB of Russia in 550 from the commander tank Berdyansk received information the following content in accordance with provisions of the contract between the Russian Federation of Ukraine on cooperation in use of the Azov Sea and
  • 01:06:38: Kerch Strait December 24, 2003 we have the right to freedom freedom of navigation right indeed there is however the exercise of this right provides compliance with the rules referred to earlier 48 hours 24 4 pilotage dues and so then we actually to this
  • 01:07:09: the time of reconstruction was not observed further and if guided referred to the contract then actually not only need to talk about the existence of the right to freedom shipping but also actually remember about fourth paragraph if problems arise it is necessary to solve these problems on state level but proper
  • 01:07:41: politicians apparently in Kiev decided to leave the solution of those questions on place for Ukrainian sailors and in fact they had nothing else like u to mention about an international treaty and approaching the state border Russian Federation who previously like we saw recommended not to cross
  • 01:08:11: Ukrainian sailors in terms of Russian Federation already stopped trespassers further we have the message here is the general prosecutors of Ukraine in 608 just confirmation of the Ukrainian ships crossed the line of neutral waters and moved towards the Kerch Strait Further further what we see in 623 Russians
  • 01:08:41: started dangerous maneuvering and forbade the passage that is, even the type confirms that Russia did not prohibit pass I darpa contract and have the right to freedom of navigation yes if there are problems means it is necessary to solve all problems diplomatically next item
  • 01:09:15: reconstruction from gpu at 6:30 am in russia ultimatum demanded to leave and 12 million zones Ukraine replied what is acting with respect international norms and bilateral agreements means we can draw from this message that a Ukrainian side confirms that military boats of Ukraine were in the 12 soap zone the second thing they demanded
  • 01:09:46: leave this zone and further further what the ukrainian side acts respect between native bilateral agreements although once again indicates that there is a fourth point if here in this case and judging by the message alga plov controversy has arisen use the fourth point and actually solve issues at the level
  • 01:10:17: diplomatic and political and not on the level of ordinary sailors of servicemen here and further what we have we have the next element of reconstruction from the FSB 630 commander belt 302 to commander Berdyansk brought information about what textures in the Kerch Canal for ensure the safety of navigation there is a permissive pass order
  • 01:10:48: and carried out in accordance with approved by captain kerch schedule application for passage spilled served that is again reminded in 48 24 hours and confirmed in four hours data the requirements of the Ukrainian side is not fulfilled with and with that following Kerch canals ship navy of Ukraine prohibited in accordance with clause 20 38 before that and I was just already bringing up
  • 01:11:23: the screen is this order from October 21, 2015 of the year in the Kerch Strait permissive order of movement and ship parking following items reconstruction we have from the general prosecutors Ukraine 634 Russia began on ramparts and a battering ram and at gunpoint on Ukrainian boats circled military
  • 01:11:55: military helicopter mi-8 itself at the moment already in terms of FSB of the Russian Federation recommended by warship Ukraine does not cross the state border of the russian federation and don't go in the direction of the Kerch Strait and actually gpu confirmed what was such a requirement is Russia in ultimatum demanded to leave
  • 01:12:26: for us, the family zone Ukraine replied what is valid compliance international norms actually reaction reaction of russia certainly expected and if Ukrainian side violates the rules then the Russian side is applying which applies in this case to the shafts and sides to stop
  • 01:12:57: violators of the border of the Russian Federation and here is just the next element reconstruction from the FSB 701 in such and such the coordinates of the navy ships of Ukraine crossed the state border line Russian Federation and should Kerch Strait in violation already in In this case, the UN Convention on Maritime the right and all the same articles 12 points 2 federal law 155 on domestic
  • 01:13:32: sea ​​waters that we have written in paragraph 3 of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea Now we will display it what does the item say here third point 3 coastal state can without discrimination by form or by essentially between and nostra
  • 01:14:02: between foreign courts temporarily suspend in certain areas of its territorial sea exercise of the right of peaceful passage foreign ships if such suspension from essential for guarding it security including conducting exercises with using a weapon such a cross on the suspension takes effect only after should have its publication and how we saw it showed
  • 01:14:34: demonstrated such an alert was on the moment is getting clear and the next item reconstruction from the FSB at 720 pskr house and press as emerald took measures to prevent the passage of the navy of Ukraine Ukrainian channels were called to Kerch channels ship radio communications did not require poorer slowly leave
  • 01:15:04: Russian territorial sea federations in accordance with Article 30 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea and requirements to leave the territorial sea sea ​​of ​​the russian federation navy ships Ukraine ignored means what us for article 30 of the un convention let's let's see this article 30 if any warship is not abides by coastal laws and regulations
  • 01:15:34: states concerning passage through territorial sea ignores any appeal to him about their demands respecting coastal state can this is a possibility may require him immediately leave the territorial sea like that story in this case further what we have goes for reconstruction event the next item
  • 01:16:05: from gpu 752 berdyansk berdyansk pick up requested a pass through the channel this let's say so testimony to ourselves that what is called that is an hour earlier according to reconstruction reconstruction gpu the boats were for the good Ukrainian leadership if logical generally reason should have been withdrawn boats and find out all the diplomatic
  • 01:16:35: agree in the same way to the fourth international treaty joint use of the Sea of ​​Azov and the Kerch Strait and boats according to this element reconstruction for forgiveness passage through the Kerch channel in general is continued obvious provocation she is so looks even in reconstruction year type scratch and shoot us sink us a boat or to and and or like this
  • 01:17:06: looks like i remind how she looked in execution of the Ukrainian border guards when they actually dealt with Turkish schooner who eventually sank I have already demonstrated there is still one element on here from FSB 835 navy ships Ukraine were brought into combat readiness and split artillery artillery barrels
  • 01:17:38: installations are raised at a 45 degree angle and directed towards the ships and boats Russian Federation in violation of the article 19 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea 82 years and everything is no longer there it should not very point 2 of article 11 of the federal Law 155 Russian side brought before the navy ships of Ukraine that in territorial sea of russia threatened
  • 01:18:08: use of weapons will be considered as a violation of international law and legislation of the Russian Federation but let's look at article 19 the un convention on the law of the sea what does it says there means this article 30 on enter max from e to article 19 what does the government say there article 19 passage is peaceful if
  • 01:18:41: only they do not break the good world order here is a good order has already been broken or coastal state security Russian suspicions were by about coastal safety state such passes must performed in accordance with the present career convention and other norms international law but at least good order namely the rule of passage ukrainian side were violated here
  • 01:19:12: such a story and further we know that Ukrainian ships together with Ukrainian the sailors were detained and It should be noted that such a thing business Ukrainian sailors were undertaken then they served orders from their point of view not in my opinion not there were reasons to suspect
  • 01:19:44: that they perform some kind of criminal orders and so i think that at least simple little sailors in what are they guilty of doing the order and their actually if it is fair to argue it is necessary to let go home to Ukraine and the situation is such that they are and probably will be condemned i mean they will get some court decision and only after that after
  • 01:20:17: this go home i hope that it will happen after the election President of Ukraine because with current authorities the Russian side to negotiate not maybe about this several times already declared at the highest level ship commanders possible too fulfilled the order but these are from rushniki who were there perhaps possessed more information about these the official Kiev slats will probably be
  • 01:20:50: the story is different well here but anyway anyway thank god there were no casualties and how I said earlier the Crimean problem it is necessary to decide to decide on interstate level and in custody I want to go through the elements that
  • 01:21:21: presented to the Russian side in as a violation as an international treaties and international law in parts of the convention on the law of the sea and own laws of the Russian Federation and i will start the already mentioned international the contract here is the contract I have it showed affirms that russia violated article 4 where spelled
  • 01:21:58: provision that including warships Russia of Ukraine in the Sea of ​​Azov Kerch Strait enjoys freedom shipping but since contradictions issues and during the reconstruction it was visible therefore it is worth using the article 4 disputes between the parties in this article
  • 01:22:28: said related interpretation and attention by applying the present agreement is allowed by consultation and negotiation as well as other peaceful means the choice of the parties the keyword peaceful by means the next element in which usually accuses the Russian Federation is in violations of international law and exactly the maritime law conventions and i
  • 01:22:59: right now this convention will display again here is this conversion we have already disassembled article 25 point 3 what proper coastal state can temporarily suspend in certain areas of its territorial sea implementation of the right of peaceful passage foreign ships if such suspension is essential and tarot Tota such suspension comes into
  • 01:23:29: force only after his due publishing this moment we already disassembled but important and proper read article 25 fully and in particular item first coastal the state can take in its territorial sea measures are necessary for prevent the passage of non peaceful it matters second regarding ships bound internal waters or using
  • 01:24:01: port facilities outside inland waters coastal state also has the right to take the necessary measures to prevent any violation conditions on which these here are allowed into the internal waters and use the port facilities actually have a rule passages of the Kerch Strait about which we already said this more than once it is necessary application send 48 hours 2 times 24 hours and
  • 01:24:31: actually finally approved a four hour pass there is also claims to the Russian side about violation of Article 30 Now we will show it in our article 30 a here is article 30 if any military
  • 01:25:01: ships not abides by coastal laws and regulations here are the Ukrainian states in particular military boats relating goes through territorial sea and ignores any appeal to him about their demands respecting coastal state can request him to leave immediately territorial sea that is here says that if the Ukrainian the party did not follow the rules and ignored any creams then actually
  • 01:25:31: the Russian side could demand leave these ships territorial the sea they arrest them but here the key word may that is actually This article enables them limitation requirements Here is such a story there are also such frames famous legal lovers sophisms as actually and Andrei
  • 01:26:03: Illarionov is such a character former adviser to the president of russian Federation here his opinion will be with familiar with it here Illarionov refers here to The following articles of the UN Convention maritime law but really must read article 17 and
  • 01:26:33: understand exactly what this article is about what In general, the whole section of these articles let's we read means 20 articles where we have 17 a little higher here is section number three peaceful passage in the territorial sea on article 17 subject to of this convention, the courts of all states
  • 01:27:03: both coastal and not breathing out landlocked enjoy the right attention peaceful passage through the territorial the sea and there is actually a question and was it an attempt by the Ukrainian military boats pass through the strait of Kerch peacefully I remember that april 2018 supreme glad Ukraine passed a law and this one
  • 01:27:35: the law on the screen is according to this to the law Russia Russia was recognized aggressor country here in article 2 I'm about this is a mention of this law this law sets territory status of Ukraine temporarily occupied by armed aggression Russian Federation that is Russia
  • 01:28:06: recognized by the Ukrainian side aggressor country and what that means This means that there are warships. the country that recognizes the Russian aggressor side and if so proper Ukrainian side warships too just can't pass peacefully through that more through those the waters that are actually peninsula
  • 01:28:37: which we resort these waters which Ukraine considers occupied and in terms of Russian Federation Ukrainian side is the country which Russia recognizes ogres and is it possible to talk about applying articles of the UN Convention on maritime law which refers to peaceful passage, I think you can not and the final moment in which usually
  • 01:29:12: accuses the Russian Federation and particular the same larion and not only he is that Russia is also violated its own legislation in particular federal law number 155 it means what you have when you're alone about the same then there is article 12 this law and now I will bring it to
  • 01:29:43: The screen I display on the screen so this appears The article on the screen and here it is federal law 155 and there are people from 12 to article 12 article about everything about the same ladies in
  • 01:30:15: security interests Russian Federation about what this article practically repeats the twenty fifth article on convention persons on maritime part three right suspension the right of innocent passage takes effect after proactively announcing this in the notices to mariners and actually this notice was as already showed earlier
  • 01:30:48: here as well as I should note that in the same law has article 15 let's take a look at her Article 15 means us to illustrate interested in point 5 then why are we interested because in notifications
  • 01:31:19: Mariners had reports that closed areas were temporarily dangerous sometimes it pays attention to temporality that is, the possibility of passing means point 5 what does it mean temporarily dangerous to all ships and warships Russian Federation Foreign Courts foreign warships and others
  • 01:31:50: state here as well as all others floating equipment are required to perform rules are set for forbidden for swimming and temporarily dangerous this is important time to swim dangerous for the edge of he reference to ignorance of the rules or the border forbidden to swim or temporarily hazardous areas for swimming cannot serve as a basis for calls such areas and evasion
  • 01:32:20: under responsibility this is the situation with interpretation of terms of time dangerous means again I want to draw attention to the fact that this article is she refers to the peaceful passage and the passage as we already understand was not copper according to Besides leaf of a vessel not a bit as far as I I remember this passage was at least
  • 01:32:53: secretive they are peace according the resolution adopted by the laws of the Supreme are happy Russian Federation has been recognized aggressor country here therefore as I said earlier pass and warships of the country who recognize Russia aggressors through the fact that occupied and can hardly consider an attempt at a peaceful passage means it is also alleged that the Russian
  • 01:33:34: the federation violated its own federal law number 155 now I have it I will display on the screen and here is article 19 part 3 which reads as follows when use of foreign warship weapons against the russian federation and ships and aircraft or citizens of the Russian Federation countermeasures to repel an attack carried out in accordance with the law
  • 01:34:06: Russian Federation on state border of Russia and the charter of the organization United Nations actually incomprehensible why this article is presented Russian Federation because we are all we know that the Ukrainian side is not used weapons and this is an article and the third Part 19 of the article just says what to do in the case of weapons The argument is usually such that the Russian
  • 01:34:38: side applied weapons and on which the basis here is part 3 of article 19 says what is needed that on the opposite side 1 used a weapon from here and the question is, on what basis Russia used weapons and now we we will display this this basis so here's the document and what is it called?
  • 01:35:09: we have this government decree of the Russian Federation on February 24, 2010 of the year number there 80 interests us points 24 and 25 then here is point 24 decision on the use of weapons to kill border ships before being taken the head of the border authority or
  • 01:35:40: person acting as his twenty-fifth point yourself decides on the use of weapons and military equipment officers commander border ship for the necessary defense or in extreme conditions necessary when the delay in the use of weapons creates immediate danger to their lives and health in general these points are twenty five and twenty
  • 01:36:10: fourth exhausted grounds on which border guards themselves Russian Federation so applied weapons also claimed that the Russian the federation has broken all the same federal law number 155 and in this case article 23
  • 01:36:43: part 2 right of the Russian Federation in contiguous zone and in this case indicated violation due to the fact that the question is, which one Based Russian Federation detained and military boats and actually sailors read what says part 2 of article 23 in the contiguous zone
  • 01:37:13: Russian Federation takes action necessary to prevent violations referred to in paragraph 1 of this article and detention of perpetrators including hot pursuit stop inspection and detention of all foreign ships violator except warships and others state courts are key here of course there is an indication why
  • 01:37:43: it is claimed that this article is violated because we are dealing with Ukrainian military boats are not in this case the question arises whether we are dealing with adjacent area then there is such an article that such territorial waters let's read this paragraph
  • 01:38:13: in fact, I don't know how in that place considered territorial waters but this option must also be considered means the countdown of territorial waters comes from the line of greatest ebb if the shore has a calm outline then there is if calm outlines means here from the line of the largest archives either from boundaries of inland waters either from so
  • 01:38:47: called imaginary baselines straight lines connecting the protrusions of the front in the sea ​​if the coast is deeply indented attention is tortuous or if near coast is a chain of islands means with what what situation are we dealing here i drew here our situation here is the Crimean peninsula and here's a meandering shore can this calm
  • 01:39:19: period wear meandering mean here there are two ledges there is that imaginary line there instead of major events where was retention and the straight line itself and actually here below there is information about the distance Further, the second point in this case is
  • 01:39:50: also conventions on the high seas happiness and and will display this one convention here is an open sea convention we are interested in article 23 and what does she say about opportunities to detain violators pursuit of a foreign ship may
  • 01:40:20: be undertaken if competent coastal state authority has reason to believe that this the ship violated the laws and regulations of this State of prosecution should start then when a foreign ship or one of his boats is in inland waters and in territorial sea ​​sea or in contiguous zone pursuing state and can continue outside territorial sea that is not so
  • 01:40:51: fundamentally this adjacent zone was or inland waters also also by about the grounds on which acted border guards i want to also draw attention to federal law from 22 December 2014 number 446 in this law
  • 01:41:22: what is happening, he says that the border border authorities in border area has right to that what do they have the right to pursue delay outside territorial waters this paragraph 19 dariya when became
  • 01:41:54: chase and hold outside territorial waters of the Russian Federation ship violating international treaties Russian Federation Federal Laws and other regulatory legal acts Russian Federation before calling of this vessel in its territorial sea country actually the internal one legislation of the Russian Federation
  • 01:42:26: Russian Federation have the right to bloom Well, in the end, we summarize the thesis and so a few days after the Kerch of events FSB of the Russian Federation published ship control sheet ship nikopol Whereby the passage was planned at least hidden including the hidden passage through
  • 01:42:58: Kerch Strait as it is currently represented the Kiev authorities to implement peacefully let's say so without appropriate Russian side meeting is the first moment the second moment is that Ministry of Defense of Ukraine classified the information did not betray and official status what is it really planned in Kiev as a passage boats on military boats navy of Ukraine
  • 01:43:31: the third is worth paying again attention is Alexander Shevchenko dill party representatives who warned of impending provocation in Sea of ​​Azov in order to impose martial law and try to cancel the presidential election further we traced on reconstruction and FSB and gpu before the time when it is already with the Ukrainian side
  • 01:44:04: point of view of the Russian Federation was considered a trespasser who did not complied with the relevant rules for passage through the Kerch Strait That is, we stopped at that moment when went arrest and use of weapons Russian side in order to stop violators state borders from to during the reconstruction we saw that
  • 01:44:37: Ukrainian side preferred enjoy 2 2 articles of international agreement between Ukraine and Russia on joint use of the Sea of ​​Azov and the Kerch Strait where it is said about free shipping but for some reason forget to ignore that article where it says that if there are questions about the application of this contract you must actually communicate at the top they are at sea
  • 01:45:09: simple sailors as with the Russian parties from the Ukrainian side as well could lead to the corresponding tragedy to the victims of the sunk boat as we have seen I demonstrated Ukrainian border guards performing their duties need it too stress stopped and delayed Turkish schooner in due time as a result we we have that 20 according to my 24 ukrainian
  • 01:45:42: the military is now in the Russian side Apparently there will be a court and a court decision on about these sailors as violators state border again elections will be in Ukraine will be the ability to change authorities and the new dialogue between Moscow and Kiev, I hope that the sailors will soon time to return home to Ukraine and this is likely to occur in
  • 01:46:15: framework of the exchange of citizens of Ukraine for citizens Russian Federation Well, again, I wanted to demonstrate the cherry on the cake is also an important moment literally the day after imposing martial law this check leaves now show something other
  • 01:46:46: here is facebook page oksana kirilenko this is actually the director of the nkr kp and she in her albeit on facebook announces the following that tariffs for pumping gas through the Ukrainian gas hf reduced by more than half
  • 01:47:16: the question actually arises for which gas tariffs are reduced and for what side of no gas other than Russian through the ukrainian hts towards europe pumped over here again such hybrid situation on the one hand Russian aggression before the introduction of martial law and right there reduced tariff for pumping Russian gas for Gazprom is such a hybrid
  • 01:47:48: aggressive gas through ukrainian gas transmission system well and actually the most important question here is me too a lot of things said about this video but you don't have to forget about it the main factory that in 2018 Ukraine recognized the Russian Federation aggressor country and need to actually decide either Ukraine aggression with
  • 01:48:20: Russia or the world and if aggression with Russia is actually about what peaceful passage can be talk because that in terms of the Russian Federation Ukrainian side is the country which already at the legal level Russia recognizes the aggressor here such a hybrid situation and actually this hybrid is necessary level of hybrid sti need to be reduced and I
  • 01:48:51: I hope that after the elections president whatever the results I hope that a new dialogue will begin between Moscow and Kiev on permission many accumulated problems that we observed as a consequence of the Maidan and revolution of poverty thank you for your attention those who watched and not subscribed subscribe because and as usual
  • 01:49:23: we have the most interesting thing ahead